HomeMy WebLinkAboutPR 11961:DEMOLITION (GROUP D)To: SteVe Fitzgibbons, City Manager
From: Lawrence Baker, Director of Community Servi~es/~
Date: September 27, 2002
Re:
P. R. NO. 11961 - AWARDING A CONTRACT TO COASTAL DEMOLITION,
.INC. FOR DEMOLITION OF FOUR (4) DANGEROUS RESIDENTIAL
STRUCTURES (GROUP D) LOCATED THROUGHOUT THE CITY
~OMME~ NT
RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the City Council adopt P. R. No. 11961
authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract with Coastal Demolition. Inc. in the amount of
$7.150.00 for the demolition and removal of four (4) dangerous residential Structures located
throughout the City.
BACK~: Bids for twenty-two (22) structures were opened on .September 26, ,2002.
Coastal Demolition, Inc. is the 10w bi,ta~r for Group D'- their bid was $7.150.00 to be
completed Within six (6) working days. Bid award is based on the lowes{"and most responsive
bid. Prov~§t Demolition and Constmction's bid was $8,400.00 (8 da~sj; and Greater Texas
EnvironmEntal, Inc.'s bid was $10,I00.00 (no estimate of days was given). A bid tabulation follows:
CONTRACTOR GROUP D
Provost Demolition & Construction
Port Arthur, TX ' $ 8,400.00
Greater Texas Environmental, Inc.
Warren, TX $10,100.00
*Coastal Demolition, Inc.
Beaumont, TX $ 7,150.00
*Successful Bidder
Six contractors were notified of the bids. The contractors who were notified but did not respond
were: (1) C & C Demolition, Inc. of Orange, Texas; (2) C. M. Independent Contracting of
Beaumont, Texas; (3) Cherry Demolition of Houston, Texas; and (4) Senior Citizen Demolition of
Port Arthur, Texas.
(CONTINUED)
P. tL # 11961 - DEMO CONTRACT - COASTAL DEMO? INC~ 09.27-02 PAGE 2 OF 2
BUI~ET AND REVENUE IMPACT: Acceptance of this recommendation w/Il not require a
budget amendment. Funds are available in Account No. 105-1431-552.59-00, Project No. C28120.
STAFF LEVEL IMPACT: Acceptance of t]~ recommendation ~ 'hage no effect on current
sta~ing level '.
SUMMARy:- staff recommends that the City Coun. cil adopt P. R. No. 11961, thereby authorizing
the execution of a demolition contract between the City of Port Arthur and Coastal Demolition,
Inc. in the amount of $7~150.00. -
STRUCTUREs TO BE DEMOLISHED:
01. 3015 6m Street (Burned Residence)
02. 3126 8m Street (Residence/Shed)
03. 736 I1~ Avenue (Residence)
04. 3825 5~h Street (Garage)
,+
P. R. No. 11961
09/27/02 DTP
RESOLUTION NO.
A RESOLUTION AWARDING A CONTRACT TO
COASTAL DEMOLITION, INC. IN THE AMOUNT OF
$7,1~0.00, AND AUTHORIZING THE EXECLY~DN ~)F A
CONTRACT FOR THE D~CIOLITION OF" FoUR (4)
DANGEROUS RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES (GROUP D),
TO BE CHARGED TO ACCOUNT NO. 105-1431-552.59-00,
· PROJECT NO. C28120.
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITM COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PORT ARTHUR:
THAT the City Council of the City of Port Arthur hereby awards a contract for the demolition
of four (4) dangerous residential properties in the City of Port Arthur, to the best and lowest responsible bidder
to-wit: Coastal Demolitlon~ Inc.; and,
THAT the City Manager of the City of Port Arthur is hereby authorized and directed to execute
on behalf of the City of Port Arthur an agreement between the City of Port Arthur and Coastal Demolition~
Inc. for the contract price of $7~150.00 (a copy of said contract is attached hereto.as Exhibit "A"5; and,
THAT Said contract is a duplicate of the standard form Contract previously approved by the City's
Legal Department .~cept for the changes shown on the Certificate of Standard F(~rm Contract, a copy of which
is attached hereto and is hereby incorporated by reference as Exhibit "B', and said changes are hereby approved;
and,
THAT a copy of the caption of this Resolution be spread upon the Minutes of the City Council.
READ, ADOPTED, AND APPROVED this the
day of October, A.D., 2002, at a
Regular Meeting of the City Council of the City of Port Arthur, Texas by the following vote:
P. R. No. 11961
09/27/02 DTP
AYES: MAYOR:
Councilmembers:
NOES:
MAYOR
ATTEST:
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
CITY SECRETARY
APPROVED FOR ADMINISTRATION:
CITY MANAGER
APPROVED AS TO AVAILABILITY OF FUNDS:
CITY ATTORNEY
~n~CTOR OF co~ SEaVlCES
.~-, ~~.~. _
DIRECTOR OF FINANCE
"EXHIBIT A"
DEMOLITION CONTRACT
CITY OF PORT ARTItUR
~-: COuI~ITy OF JEFFERSON
THE STATE OFTEXAS
THIS AGREEMENT is made and entered into this day of
~ 2002, by and between the City of Port Arthur, hereinafter called
the "CITY", and Coastal Demolition, Inc., hereinafter called the "CONTRACTOR", in
consideration of the mutual agreements contained herein and for a total sum of Seven
thousand, one hundred fifty dollars and no cents ($7,150.00); we do hereby agree to
all terms, conditions and specifications contained herein and attached hereto; and we do
hereby declare VALID this AGREEMENT and CONTRACT:
SECTION I
WITNESSETH:
THE CONTRACTOR SHALL:
A. Furnish all labor, materials, tools, machinery, qualified supervision and all other
items and services necessary for satisfactory completion of specifications and
agreements contained herein for demolition of structures and cleanup at ~he
property described as GROUP D, described in the attached bid sheets. ":
B. Start',. the herein specified work within _5 days from th~: above date of tiffs
AGREEMENT AND CONTRACT, and furthermore, diligently pursue same until
satisfactorily completed on or before the day o.f ~
2002 [within six (6) working days], time being of the essence. It is further
understood that if the contract is not completed by the foregoing completion date,
(or the said date as extended pursuant to provisions of this contract), the
CONTRACTOR shall be assessed liquidated damages of twenty-five dollars ($25)
per day for each day the contract is not completed after said date. All Contractors
are required to have a Landfill Permit, which includes a minimum escrow account
of five hundred dollars ($500). If you opt not to set up an escrow account, you
must pay as you dispose by cash or cashier's check.
Ce
Perform all work in accordance with the terms of this AGREEMENT and the
DEMOLITION SPECIFICATIONS attached hereto.
"EXHIBIT A'
Be responsible for obtaining all necessary and general and special permitsand pay
any and all fees for said permits and any other fees, public or private, which may
be required by the United States, the State of Texas, Jefferson County, or the City
of Port Arthur, to satisfactorily complete the work as specified and agreed to
herein.
Furnish certificates of insurance to the~City's Purchasing' Agent evidencing that
the CONTRACTOR has obtained Workman's Compensati6n, General Liability
and Automobile Liability Insur~ce, which is required by the CITY for
peyformance of the work specified here. Minimum amounts of such insurance to
be obtained by the CONTRACTOR are.as follows:
Statutory Texas Workman's Compensation Insurafice (with waiver of
subrogation in favor of the City, its officers, employees and agents.
Commercial General Liability occurrence type insurance (products/
completed operations coverage must be included and the City and its
officers, employees, and agents must be named as an additional insured):
a. General Aggregate
b. Products-Comp/Ops Aggregate
c. Personal & Advertising Injury
d. Each Occurrence
e. Fire Damage
$500,000
$500,000
$500,000
$500,000
.$.50,000
· Commercial Automobile Liability (including owned, non-6wned, and hired
vehicles coverage). -
a. Bodily Injury (per person)
b: Bodily Injury (per accident)
c. ProPerty Damage
$300,000
$500,000
$100,000
4. Contractor Surety Bond
$ 5,000
Furnish to the Purchasing Agent, City of Port Arthur, prior to commencing work,
certificates of insurance meeting the above listed insurance requirements for any
sub-contractors, haulers, or independent workmen used by the CONTRACTOR in
performance of the work specified herein.
Ensure that competent and qualified supervision is present on the job site at all
times while work is in progress and that all demolition work is pursued in such a
manner as to maximize the safety of all workmen, .the general public and
surrounding property.
"EXHIBIT A'
Comply with the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and Section 109 of the Housing and
Community Development Act of 1974, to wit: No person in the United States
shall, on the ground of race, color, national origin, or sex be excluded fi.om
participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected~to discrimination under
any program or activity funded in whole or part with funds made available under
SECTION II.
THE CITY SHALL:
.Inspect the demolition work in progress to ensure that such work is being carried
out in accordance with the terms of this AGREEMENT and the DEMOLITION
SPECIFICATIONS attached hereto:
Bo
Compensate the CONTRACTOR according to the following method: Except as
hereinafter provided, payment for the Demolition Contract will be made in a lump
sum after completion and acceptance of the contract work. One progress payment
may be requested when at least fifty percent (50%) of the contract work is
completed. Ten percent (10%) of the progress payment will be reta'med. This
retainage will be held in escrow by the City for a maximum of thirty (30) days
after satisfactory completion and acceptance of the Contract to guarantee the
completion of work. Thirty (30) days after saidcompletibn.and acceptance, final
payment shall be made in a lump sum or total agreed.pric~ iess the progress
payment, if made, by check issued by the City of Port Arthur- and made payabl~ to
the CONTRACTOR for the satisfactory completion of the work, described herein.
Any payments are subject to satisfactory intermediate and final inspections by,the
City. Further, an applicable request for payment must be made by the
CONTRACTOR prior to each payment. . ·
SECTION III
General Conditions:
If performance by the CONTRACTOR is prevented or delayed as a direct result of
acts of a publ!c enemy, acts of the property owner, fire, epidemics, or acts of God,
such as floods, earthquakes, hurricanes, tornadoes and rain, an extension of one (1)
working day of additional time will be allowed to the CONTRACTOR for each
working day lost from such cause, provided the CONTRACTOR, within three (3)
days after the beginning of such delay, gives written notice to the City.
If for any reason, other than those specified above, the CONTRACTOR at any
time fails for a period of five (5) consecutive working days to supply enough
skilled workers or otherwise neglects to execute the work properly, the CITY,
after these five (5) working days may give written notice to the CONTRACTOR
terminating his contract. -~-~ -~
The CONTRACTOR shall repair' or [eplace, if necessary, to the City's
satisfaction, any damage to the work site, the adjacent areas, the access areas to
th.e work site and to any elements within these areas that may have suffered
damage as a result of the CONTRACTOR'S or any of the subcontractor's
operations. The CONTRACTOR shall leave these areas in a satisfactory and
workmanlike condition, at least equal to that existing before 'the CONTRACTOR
.hereunder started his work.
The CONTRACTOR agrees .to indemnify and hold harmless the City of Port
Arthur, Texas from any and all claims, and damages of any and every kind for
injury to or death of any person, an& damages to property arising out of the
demolition.
Any amendments to this contract shall be written and must be executed by both
the CITY and the CONTRACTOR prior to the implementation of any such
change.
This CONTRACT and AGREEMENT embodies and represents all of the rights,
duties and obligations of the CITY and the CONTRA_CTOR 'and any oral. or
writtSn agreements prior to the date first above written, not-included or embodied
herein shall be declared void and not be binding or of benefit to any of the parties
herein mentioned.
SECTION IV
Particular Requirements:
Ae
Other particular work requirements are contained in the DEMOLITION
SPECIFICATIONS, which are attached hereto and made a part hereof as Exhibit
"A 1"
ALL DEMOLITION BIDS SHALL INCLUDE REMOVAL OF CONCRETE
SLABS, PORCHES, STEPS, ETC., UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED.
"EXHIBIT A'~
SECTION V
If the CONTRACTOR materially defaults in (a) failing to have liability insurance; (b) not
completing the CONTRACT within the time required; or (c) uses demolition procedures
that are dangerous to the health and safety of residents and/0r~.adjoining residents, the
Director of Community Services has the authority to issue a-cea.ne and desist order until
this matter can be:reviewed by the City Colmcil. ~: :. ,.
SIGNED AND AGREED TO this
day of ., A.D. 2002:
COASTAL DEMOLITION, INC.
WITNESSED
SIGNED AND AGREED TO this..
,i
day Of ·
CITY OF PORT ARTHUR
BY CITY MANAGER
.,A.D. 2002:
WITNESSED
DEMOLITION SPECIFICATIONS
CITY OF PORT ARTHUR
I. TITLE
The provisions embraced within these sections and subsections shall constitute; be known as;
and will be referred to herein and in any relevant AGREEMENT and CONTRACT as
"DEMOLITION SPECIFICATIONS".
SCOPE
The scope and purpose of these specifications is to establish certain regulations, general
requirements, and particular requirements necess .aD' for the demolition, removal and cleanup of
the unsafe and/or unsanitary structure(s) as required by the Inspections Department of the City of
Port Arthur.
IlL CONTRACTOR BIDS
Contracts for the demolition of structures will be awarded in accordance with the terms and
conditions listed in the Community Services Department's BID FORM FOR DEMOLITION.
The completion 0fthe demolition package will be of vital importance to the City. The number of
calendar days given on the proposal form will be used to establish the completion date as used in
the Contract. In case the work is not completed within the time specified in the Contract, there
shall be liquidated damages of twenty-five dollars ($25) per day for each day exceeding the
completion date.
IV.
A.
INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS .. .
The Contractor shall, upon submission of bid, furnish the Ci~f with certificates of
insurance, indicating the existence of Statutory Workman's Compensation Insurance,
General and Auto Liability, Public Liability, and Property Damage Insurance. Such
insurance must be issued by a company authorized to do business in the State of Texas.
Such a certificate must contain a provision requiring not less than fifteen (15) days prior
notice in writing to the City of any change or terminatiofi of said insurance. All
insurance is to remain in force until the job of clearing the premises has been completed
and the work has been accepted by the City.
Bo
The Contractor/Successful Bidder must obtain and furnish to the City proof of insurance
in the following minimum amounts:
1. Statutory Texas Workman's Compensation Insurance;
Commercial General Liability:
a. General Aggregate
b. Products-Comp/Ops Aggregate
c. Personal & Advertising Injury
d. Each Occurrence
e. Fire Damage
1
$500,000
$5O0,0O0
$500,000
$500,000
$ 50,000
Automobile Liability
a. Bodily Injury (per person)
b. Bodily Injury (per accident)
c. Property Damage
$300,000
$500,000
$100,000
4. Contractor Surety Bond $ 5,000
V. PERMITS '. ': -: :
The Contractor/Successful Bidder must obtain from the City of Port Arthur and all other
governmental entities, at his own expense,' afl necessary general and special permits and pay any
and ail fees for said permits and any other fees, pub. lic or private.
All Contractors are required to have a Landfill Permit, which includes a minimum escrow
account of five hundred dollars ($500). If you opt not to set up an escrow account,'you
must p~iy cash or by cashier's check as you dispose.
VI. GENERAL CONDITIONS AND REQUIREMENTS
The following list of conditions and requirements are to be understood as being a general guide
in the demolition of structures. It must be noted, however, that there are special requirements
listed below in Section VII of these specifications, which are in addition to these general
requirements for demolition, and that it is the responsibility of the Contractor/Successful Bidder
to comply with ail particular requirements.
A. It is understood and agreed that the Contractor/Successful Bidder will function ::and
operate as an independent contractor. Any liability incurred by the C~0ntractor/Successful
Bidder will accrue only to that party as an independent contractor and not to the Cio of
Port Arthur.
No Work under a City DEMOLITION CONTRACT shall be subcontracted by'.the
Contractor/Successful Bidder without prior, written approval of the Community
Services Department. No subcontractor will be approved unless that subcontractor meets
the same insurance requirements specified for and required of the Contractor.
The demolition work specified herein shall be performed in a safe, satisfactory condition,
starting with the roof and working down, with the safety and welfare of all people and
property being of the highest priority.
All materiais, debris, and rubble from the demolition of the structure(s) specified herein
will become the property of the Contractor/Successful Bidder. Saivage can only begin
immediately prior to the begirming of demolition.
Eo
The Contractor/Successful Bidder will be held responsible for repair of broken or
damaged water, gas, or any other type of lines, which occur during the course of the
demolition work. The Contractor shall repair or replace, if necessary, to the City's
satisfaction, any damage to the work site, the adjacent areas, the access areas to the work
site and to any elements within these areas that may have suffered damage as a result of
2
Go
the Contractor's or any of the subcontractor's operations. The Contractor shall leave
these areas in a satisfactory condition.
The Contractor/Successful Bidder shall haul off all debris and unsalvageable materials;
and no debris or rubble which may pose a threat to public safety will be left on the site
overnight. No such debris or material will be placed on a sidewalk or public right-of-way
so that it poses a danger to any person.
All demolition work must be carded out .to the satisfaction~of the City's Inspections
Official. :'
The City (without prejudice to any other right or remedy it may have) has the right to
terminate the contract in the event '6f any default by the Contractor after giving the
Contractor seven (7) days written notice. Such notice of termination shall be subsequent
to default by the Contractor and after rec&iving written notice from the City certifying
cause for such action. In addition to other events of default or grOunds for termination
identified in the contract, it shall be considered default by the Contractor whenever he/she
'~hall:
Declare bankruptcy, become insolvent, or assign his/her assets for the benefit of'
his/her creditors.
2. Violate or disregard provisions of the Contract or instruction from the Owner.
Fail to prosecute the work according to the agreed Schedule of Completion,
including amendments and/or modifications thereof.
4. Fail to provide a qualified superintendent, competent workmen or subcontractors, '
or proper materials, or failure to make promp~ payment the~ef0r. , ..
If the. Contract is terminated as provided above or as provided kn the Contract, the City
will engage another contractor to complete the work. Payment for'the completion of such
work will come from funds obligated by the City under its contract with the original
Contractor.
METHOD OF PAYMENT
Payment shall be made as provided in Section II of the contract..
PAYMENT WITHHELD
Any part or the whole of any payment may be withheld by the City to the extent deemed
necessary and reasonable should evidence of the following be discovered:
1. Defective work not corrected.
Claims filed against the Contractor.
Reasonable evidence indicating the probability of filing claims against the
Contractor.
3
4. Failure of the Contractor to make proper payments to subcontractors or for
materials or for labor.
5. The contract cannot be completed for the then unpaid balance.
6. Unsatisfactory progress of the work by the Contractor.
When the above grounds are removed, the amount withheld because:~ them shall be paid to the
Contractor subject to and within the other terms :~f this contract. ~'
L. CONTRACT PAYMENT RETAINAGE
Contract payment retainage shall be as provided in the Contract.
VII. PARTICUL3~R WORK REQUIREMENTS
The following particular work requirements and conditions apply specifically to the building(s)
or structure(s) which are located at and described as:
GROUP D 'T-YPE OF STRUCTURE
3015 6'a Street Burned Residence
3126 8'h Street Residence/Shed
736 11 d, Avenue Residence
3825 5'h Street Garage
Before any building or structure is demolished, its utilities shall be Safely disconnected.
The Contractor shall serve notice to all suppliers of utilities to'.i the building to' be
demolished and have them disconnect the services and remove all meters and equipment
belonging to them. Forty-eight (48) hours' written notice must' b~ given the City for
termination of their utilities. All piping and wiring shall be properly terminated. _Any
costs incurred in the termination of utilities and services shall be borne by the Contractor.
Demolition and clean-up includes, but is not limited to, the removal of all lumber,.do0rs,
windows, wire, sheet metal, appliances, furniture, loose rock, biSck, mortar, concrete, and
the cleaning and removal of all rubbish, trash or other debris that would inhibit or prevent
the mechanical mowing of said lot and promises.
Fill, grade and level with clean fill dirt all depressions in the earth which exist beneath
demolished building(s) or structure(s) and all ruts or other depressions created during the
demolition work when the average depth of such depressions exceeds three (3) inches.
Any trees and shrubs designated by the Community Services Department will be cut
down and removed from the premises.
The grass at the demolition site shall be mowed to a height not exceeding two (2) inches.
Fo
All sewer lines exposed through demolition work must be cut off within two (2) inches of
the surface to the ground or concrete slab and must be plugged with concrete in such a
manner as to prevent ground water incursion into the City's sanitary sewer system.
REMOVAL OF STEPS AND CONCRETE PORCHES UNLESS OTHERWISE
NOTED.
HAZARDOUS MATERIALS
Ma!erials defined by the Environmental :PrOtection Aget~¢y:itc~. be hazardous to the
environment or persons, shall be dlspose~] of in accordance :with all local, state and
federal government regulations and'~ovemlng laws. This Shall be the responsibility of
the Contractor. The Contractor shall furnish written proof of such disposal.
BOND REQUIREMENTS
If the amount bid on the contract exceeds $25,000, the Contractor will be required to
~fumish a Performance Bond and a Labor and Material Payment Bond in the amount of
$100% of the Contract on forms furnished by the City.
(Law Department)
(Required Form)
(0?/0s/ss)
(03/~/~0)
(p. 2 RevVed
P.R. # 11961
Exhibit"B"
(City of Port Arthur)
CERTIFICATE OF STANDARD FORM CONTRACT FOR LAW
DEPARTMENT REVIEW AND CITY COUNCIL AG_.~ENDA
I certify that the contract (hereinafter called ~said cOnt~gct") affixed to ~h'~ a~tached proposed City Council
Resolution No. 11961 is an exact duplicate Qf an applicable standard form c~ntract (the title of which is
shown below) previously approved by the Law Department and adopted as a standard form by City Council
Resolution, except for the blanks that have been f'dled in with all necessary information and except for the changes
described below.
Tl~e title of the applicable standard form contract is:
[ ] Federally Funded Construction Contract, ~evised 01/05/88, 07/89, 08/89
Il
Il
[]
Non-Federally Funded Construction Contract, Revised 01/05188, 07/89, 08/89
Federal - Professional Services - Engineering Contract, Revised 01/05/88, 05/89, 07/89, 04/91
Non-Federal - Professional Service~ - Engineering Contract, Revised 01/05/88, 05/89(810),
07/89(§8)
CDBG - Professional Services - Engineering Contract, Revised 01/05/88, 05/89,8 07/89§
[]
Federal - Professional Services - Non-Engineering (Consultant) contract, Revised 01/05/88,
05/89(§10), 07/89(§8)
[]
IX] '
Non-Federal - Professional Services - Non-Engineering (Consultant) Contract Revised 01/05/88,
05/89 (810), 07/89(§8)
CDBG - Professional Services - Non-Engineering (Consultant) C0ntra% Revised 01/05/88,
05/89(810), 07/89(88) :.:!.
Other Standard Form Contract, described as follows:
: CDBG Demolition Contract
The changes are as follows: (Put an "X" in the appropriate [ ]).
[X] None.
[ ] The following described provisions at the indicated page, section, etc. of the standard form have been
deleted from said contract:
DELETIONS
Page Number
Where Deleted
Provision is
Found On
Standard Form
Section or
Paragraph No.
and Caption
Which Contains
Provision Deleted
From Form
Section or
Subparagraph No.
and Caption
Which Contains Description of
Provision Deleted Provision
From Form Deleted
P.R. #11961
Exhibit "B"
[]
The following described provisions at the indicated page, section, etc. of the
standard form have been altered, modified, replaced or otherwise changed:
.ALTERATIONS, MOD~WICATI. ONS' REPLACEMENTS, ETC.
Sub § or ' ':3
Page No. § or § No. Sub § No. '
Where & Caption of & Capti~n
Provision Standard of Standard Description
Found On ' Form which form which of Provision
Standard Contains Contain~ ' in Standard
Form Provision Provision Form
:;iPage, § & caption;
sub § & caption,
etc. of said contract
which contains
altered, etc. provision; &
Description of Alteration
etc.__:
[]
The following provisions have been added to Said Contract:
ADDITIONS
Page,. Section and Caption Subsection and
Caption, etc. of said Contract Which
Contains the Added Provision anrl
Description Thereof
I further certify that said attached proposed City Council Resolution contains the following provision: "That said
contract is an exact duplicate of a City Standard Form Contract except for the changes described in the Certificate
of Standard Form Contract, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "B" and is hereby incorporated by reference,
and Said changes are hereby approved."
I understand that this certificate will be relied on by the Law Department in reviewing and
approving (or rejecting) as to form and by the City Council in reviewing and adopting (or rejecting)
said Resolution and Contract.
Signed this 27t~ day of September, 2002.
Lawrence Baker ' '~,
Director of Community Services