HomeMy WebLinkAboutD. SEPTEMBER 23, 2008 REGULAR MEETING~~ _ .:,
I.
REGULAR MEETING -September 23, 2008
INVOCATION, PLEDGE & ROLL CALL
Councilmember Henderson gave the invocation followed with the pledge to the flag.
The City Council of the City of Port Arthur met in Regular Session on Tuesday,
September 23, 2008 at 5:40 p.m. in the City Council Chamber, City Hall, with the
following members present: Mayor Deloris "Bobbie" Prince; Mayor Pro Tem Jack
Chatman, Jr.; Councilmembers Elizabeth "Liz" Segler, Morris Albright, III, Martin Flood,
John Beard, Jr. Dawana K. Wise and Thomas J. "Tom" Henderson; City Manager Steve
Fitrgibbons, Acting City Secretary Terri Hanks, City Attorney Mark T. Sokolow and
. Sergeant At Arms Police Chief Mark Blanton.
Councilmember Robert E. "Bob" Williamson joined the Regular Meeting at 6:14 p.m.
II. PROCLAMATIONS & MINUTES
Proclamations -None
,: .
~~ .
+.
Minutes
September 15, 2008 Emergency Meeting
Upon the motion of Councilmember Albright, seconded by Councilmember Henderson
and unanimously carried, the City Council approved the above-mention minutes.
Councilmember Beard stated the following into the record:
Yes, Mayor. If I will...I did not attend the Special Meeting that was held.
And, I want you to make this for the record. Because I was not informed
about that meeting, and that is why I was not in attendance. So, I am
saying that for the record. Thank you.
III. PETITIONS & COMMUNICATIONS
A. Sneakers -None
B. Presentations -None
C. Correspondence -None
IV. PUBLIC HEARINGS - None
V. UNFINISHED BUSINESS -None
VI. CONSENT AGENDA
Upon the motion of Councilmember Henderson, seconded by Councilmember Wise and
,i carried unanimously, the following Consent Agenda was adopted:
Expense Report
Mayor Deloris "Bobbie° Prince
Travel during Hurricane Ike
532 miles $ 308.56
Resolutions -Consent
(i) P.R. No. 14862 - A Resolution authorizing the execution of
an agreement to share operating expenses of Rose Hill
between the City of Port Arthur and the Federated
Women's Club of Port Arthur for the 2007 - 2008 Fiscal
Year, in an amount not to exceed $12,000, Account #140-
1405-551.59-00, M97908
Proposed Resolution No. 14862 was adopted becoming Resolution No. 08-387.
(2) P.R. No. 14900 - A Resolution pertaining To Germer Gertz,
L.L.P. acting as legal counsel for the City of Port Arthur
Section 4A Economic Development Corporation
Proposed Resolution No. 14900 was adopted becoming Resolution No. 08-388.
(3) P.R. No. 14916 - A Resolution rescinding Resolution No.
07-504 in its entirety and accepting a water utility
easement from LRG Legacy Senior Housing of Port Arthur,
LP for the construction, installation, laying, and
maintenance of water utilities in the City of Port Arthur
Proposed Resolution No. 14916 was adopted becoming Resolution No. 08-389.
(4) P.R. No. 14925 - A Resolution requesting FEMA to continue
to assist the evacuees and eligible citizens with evacuation
costs
Proposed Resolution No. 14925 was adopted becoming Resolution No. 08-390.
VII. ITEMS REQUIRING INDIVIDUAL ACTION -NON-CONSENT
A. Ordinances
(1) P. O. No. 5927 - An Ordinance as it pertains to the
suspension of Entergy rates
The Mayor introduced the above-mentioned Proposed Ordinance.
Upon the motion by Councilmember Albright, seconded by Councilmember Henderson
and unanimously carried, Proposed Ordinance No. 5927 was adopted becoming
Ordinance No. OS-96.
Voting Yes: Mayor Prince; Mayor Pro Tem Chatman; Councilmembers Segler, Albright,
Flood, Beard, Wise and Henderson.
Voting No: None.
The caption of Ordinance No. 08-96 reads as follows:
ORDINANCE NO. 08-96
AN ORDINANCE AS IT PERTAINS TO THE
SUSPENSION OF ENTERGY RATES
(2) P. O. No. 5905 - An Ordinance adopting a tax rate for the
Tax Year 2008 (Fiscal Year October i, 2008 -September
30, 2009)
The City Manager introduced the above-mentioned Proposed Ordinance.
Upon the motion by Councilmember Albright, seconded by Councilmember Henderson
and unanimously carried, Proposed Ordinance No. 5905 was adopted becoming
Ordinance No. 08-97.
City Council Minutes
Regular Meeting -September 23, 2008 Z
Voting Yes: Mayor Prince; Mayor Pro Tem Chatman; Councilmembers Segler, Albright,
Flood, Beard, Wise and Henderson.
Voting No: None.
The caption of Ordinance No. 08-97 reads as follows:
ORDINANCE NO.08-97
AN ORDINANCE ADOPTING A TAX RATE FOR
THE TAX YEAR 2008 (FISCAL YEAR OCTOBER 1,
2008 -SEPTEMBER 30, 2009)
(3) P.O. No. 5906 - An Ordinance approving the 2008 Tax Roll
for the Use and Support of the Municipal Government of
the City of Port Arthur; and providing for the interest and
sinking fund and apportioning each levy for a specific
purpose
The City Manager introduced the above-mentioned Proposed Ordinance.
Upon the motion by Councilmember Albright, seconded by Councilmember Henderson
and unanimously carried, Proposed Ordinance No. 5906 was adopted becoming
Ordinance No. 08-98.
Voting Yes: Mayor Prince; Mayor Pro Tem Chatman; Councilmembers Segler, Albright,
Flood, Beard, Wise and Henderson.
Voting No: None.
The caption of Ordinance No. 08-98 reads as follows:
ORDINANCE NO. 08-98
AN ORDINANCE APPROVING THE 2008 TAX
ROLL FOR THE USE AND SUPPORT OF THE
MUNICIPAL GOVERNMENT OF THE CITY OF
PORT ARTHUR; AND PROVIDING FOR THE
INTEREST AND SINKING FUND AND
APPORTIONING EACH LEVY FOR A SPECIFIC
PURPOSE
(4) P.O. No. 5930 - An Appropriations Ordinance amending the
Budget for the Fiscal Year beginning October i, 2007 and
ending September 30, 2008 to fund increased health
insurance costs
The City Manager introduced the above-mentioned Proposed Ordinance.
Upon the motion by Councilmember Albright, seconded by Councilmember Henderson
and unanimously carried, Proposed Ordinance No. 5930 was adopted becoming
Ordinance No. 08-99.
Voting Yes: Mayor Prince; Mayor Pro Tem Chatman; Councilmembers Segler, Albright,
Flood, Beard, Wise and Henderson.
Voting No: None.
The caption of Ordinance No. 08-99 reads as follows:
City Council Minutes
Regular Meeting -September 23, 2008 3
ORDINANCE NO.08-99
AN APPROPRIATIONS ORDINANCE AMENDING
THE BUDGET FOR THE FISCAL YEAR
BEGINNING OCTOBER 1, 2007 AND ENDING
SEPTEMBER 30, 2008 TO FUND INCREASED
HEALTH INSURANCE COSTS
(5) P.O. No. 5941- An Ordinance providing for Holiday Pay for
the fiscal year 2008/2009 (Requested by Mayor Prince)
The City Manager introduced the above-mentioned Proposed Ordinance.
The motion was made by Councilmember Albright and seconded by Councilmember
Henderson that Proposed Ordinance No. 5941 be adopted.
Assistant City Manager and Human Resources Director Harvey Robinson appeared
before the City Council to address inquiries related to the proposed holiday pay and
recommended the establishment of an eligibility date.
The motion was made by Councilmember Albright and seconded by Councilmember
Beard that Proposed Ordinance No. 5941 include the following amendment:
"That all permanent, full-time city employees, hired on October 1, 2008
and still employed in the first pay period in December 2008, will receive
$100 in holiday pay on December 19, 2008."
Proposed Ordinance No. 5941 was adopted becoming Ordinance 08-100.
Voting Yes: Mayor Prince; Mayor Pro Tem Chatman; Councilmembers Segler, Albright,
Flood, Beard, Wise and Henderson.
Voting No: None.
The caption of Ordinance No. 08-100 reads as follows:
ORDINANCE NO. 08-100
AN ORDINANCE PROVIDING FOR HOLIDAY
PAY FOR THE FISCAL YEAR 2008/2009
(REQUESTED BY MAYOR PRINCE)
(6) P.O. No. 5942 - An Ordinance Amending Sections 18-33,
58-122, 110-94, And 110-97 As It Pertains To Permit
Schedule, Turn-On Charge, Location Of Recreational
Vehicles, And Adjustment Of Water Bills As A Result Of
Hurricane Ike, And Providing An Effective Date .
The City Manager introduced the above-mentioned Proposed Ordinance.
The City Attorney distributed revisions to Sections 18-33, 58-122, 110-94 and 110-97
pertaining to Proposed Ordinance 5942 as shown in Exhibit "A" of the Meeting Minutes.
The motion was made by Councilmember Albright and seconded by Councilmember
Henderson that Proposed Ordinance No. 5942 be adopted with the revisions distributed
by the City Attorney.
Community Services Director Lawrence Baker appeared before the City Council to
address issues related to permit scheduling, turn-on charges, recreational vehicle
locations and water bill adjustments resulting from Hurricane Ike.
City Council Minutes
Regular Meeting -September 23, 2008 4
Proposed Ordinance No. 5942 was adopted as revised by the City Attorney, becoming
Ordinance No. 08-101.
Voting Yes: Mayor Prince; Mayor Pro Tem Chatman; Councilmembers Segler, Albright,
Flood, Beard, Wise and Henderson.
Voting No: None.
The caption of Ordinance No. 08-101 reads as follows:
ORDINANCE NO.OS-101
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING SECTIONS 18-33,
58-122, 110-94, AND 110-97 AS TT PERTAINS
TO PERMIT SCHEDULE, TURN-ON CHARGE,
LOCATION OF RECREATIONAL VEHICLES, AND
ADJUSTMENT OF WATER BILLS AS A RESULT
OF HURRICANE IKE, AND PROVIDING AN
EFFECTIVE DATE
(7) P.O. No. 5943 - An Ordinance As It Pertains To Facilitating
Electrical Hookups
The City Manager introduced the above-mentioned Proposed Ordinance.
The City Attorney distributed Exhibit "A" of Proposed Ordinance No. 5943 as shown in
Exhibit "B" of the Meeting Minutes.
Upon the motion by Councilmember Henderson, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Chatman
and unanimously carried, Proposed Ordinance No. 5943 was adopted with the inclusion
of Exhibit "A", becoming Ordinance No. 08-102.
Voting Yes: Mayor Prince; Mayor Pro Tem Chatman; Councilmembers Segler, Albright,
Flood, Beard, Wise and Henderson.
Voting No: None.
The caption of Ordinance No. 08-102 reads as follows:
ORDINANCE NO. 08-102
AN ORDINANCE AS IT PERTAINS TO
FACILITATING ELECTRICAL HOOKUPS
(8) P.O. No. 5945 - An Ordinance As It Pertains To Car
Allowances
The City Manager introduced the above-mentioned Proposed Ordinance
The motion was made by Councilmember Henderson and seconded by Mayor Pro Tem
Chatman that Proposed Ordinance No. 5945 be adopted.
Finance Director Rebecca Underhill appeared before the City Council to address
inquiries related to the proposed car allowance increase.
The motion was made by Councilmember Flood and seconded by Councilmember Beard
that Proposed Ordinance No. 5945 be amended to include increasing car allowances by
$600.00,
The following roll call vote was taken on the motion to amend Proposed Ordinance No.
5945:
City Council Minutes
Regular Meeting -September 23, 2008 5
Councilmember Albright
Councilmember Beard
Councilmember Flood
Councilmember Henderson
Councilmember Segler
Councilmember Wise
Mayor Pro Tem Chatman
Mayor Prince
"No"
"Yes"
"Yes"
"No"
"No"
"Yes"
"Yes"
"No"
The motion to amend Proposed Ordinance No. 5945 failed to carry.
The motion was made by Councilmember Henderson and seconded by Councilmember
Flood that Proposed Ordinance No. 5945 be amended to include increasing car
allowances by $300.00.
City Attorney Mark Sokolow read the following amendment into the record:
Section 3. That the car allowance for City Council members will
be increased $300 per month. This increase is in addition to the 4.5%
increase in salaries that the City Council received when the budget was
approved, effective October 1, 2008.
Voting Yes: Mayor Pro Tem Chatman; Councilmembers Segler, Albright, Flood, Wise
and Henderson.
Voting No: Mayor Prince and Councilmember Beard
The caption of Ordinance No. 08-103 reads as follows:
ORDINANCE NO. 08-103
AN ORDINANCE AS IT PERTAINS TO CAR
ALLOWANCES
Councilmember Williamson joined the Regular Meeting at 6:14 p.m.
The City Attorney announced the inclusion of the following Emergency Addendum:
EMERGENCY ADDENDUM
P. R. No. 14918 - A Resolution as it pertains to emergency debris
removal caused by Hurricane Ike and the right of entry program
The Mayor introduced the above-mentioned Proposed Resolution.
The motion was made by Councilmember Henderson and seconded by Mayor Pro Tem
Chatman that Proposed Resolution No. 14918 be approved.
The City Manager addressed contractual requirements of the Federal Emergency
Management Association (FEMA) for debris removal.
Police Chief Mark Blanton appeared before the City Council to report on hurricane debris
removal by Jefferson County.
Finance Director Rebecca Underhill appeared before the City Council to address
qualification and emergency health preclearance criteria. Mrs. Underhill commented on
private property right-of-entry program requirements.
DRC Representative David Haley, appeared before the City Council to comment on
right-of-entry program provisions. Mr. Haley addressed requirements and qualifications
for equipment operators. He discussed work force and local hiring efforts.
City Council Minutes
Regular Meeting -September 23, 2008 6
Councilmember Beard stated into the record that "Port Arthur is considered local". He
requested staff coordinate with the proposed contractor to ensure that local
employment opportunities are made available to Port Arthur citizens.
Public Works Director John Comeaux appeared before the City Council to discuss on
landfill hurricane damage and the working relationship with the proposed contractor.
Proposed Resolution No. 14918 was adopted becoming Resolution No. 08-391:
Voting Yes: Mayor Prince; Mayor Pro Tem Chatman; Councilmembers Segler, Albright,
Flood, Beard, Williamson, Wise and Henderson.
Voting No: None.
RESOLUTION NO. 08-391
A RESOLUTION AS IT PERTAINS TO
EMERGENCY DEBRIS REMOVAL CAUSED BY
HURRICANE IKE AND THE RIGHT OF ENTRY
PROGRAM
VIII. REPORTS OF BOARDS & COMMITTEES
(i) Report as to Hurricane Ike
(2) Report on damages to city infrastructure and the
prospective timetable to restore the infrastructure and
provide full services
(3) Report on FEMA and insurance reimbursements for
damages caused by Hurricane Ike
The above-mentioned reports were combined for discussion.
City Manager Fitzgibbons began Hurricane Ike discussion by addressing expenses and
potential FEMA reimbursements. The City Manager reported on debris removal and
debris removal monitoring. He addressed food and lodging provisions for essential
personnel. City Manager Fitzgibbons stated that Sabine Pass, Pleasure Island and the
City's Landfill received the heaviest damages caused by flooding.
Assistant City Manager and Human Resources Director Harvey Robinson appeared
before the City Council to address inquiries related to personnel policies for inclement
weather pay. Mr. Robinson recommended continuing discussions regarding employee
accommodations during a special meeting.
Police Chief Mark Blanton appeared before. the City Council to comment on lodging
accommodations during Hurricane Ike. Chief Blanton reported that the Holiday Inn was
used as the Command Center for emergency personnel during Hurricane Ike. The
Police Chief presented a crime report to the City Council.
Councilmember Beard requested that the names of agencies and organizations that
assisted the City of Port Arthur during Hurricane Ike be obtained for future recognition.
IX. *CLOSED MEETING (EXECUTIVE SESSION)
Closed Meeting:
Section 551.087 Government Code - To discuss incentives for
commercial, residential, and industrial business prospects
Section 551.072 Government Code - To discuss the value of land
in the City's ET)
City Council Minutes
Regular Meeting -September 23, 2008 7
Section 551.072 Government Code - To discuss the value of land
at 648 4"' Street.
The City Council recessed their meeting at 7:53 p.m. to meet in Executive Session to
consider the above-mentioned topics, and reconvened their meeting at 8:57 p.m. with
the following members present: Mayor Prince; Mayor Pro Tem Chatman;
Councilmembers Segler, Albright, Flood, Beard, Williamson and Henderson; City
Manager Fitzgibbons; Acting City Secretary Hanks, City Attorney Sokolow and Sergeant
At Arms Police Chief Mark Blanton.
Councilmember Wise left the City Council Meeting after the Executive Session.
Upon the motion of Mayor Pro Tem Chatman and seconded by Councilmember
Williamson, and carried over the dissenting vote of Mayor Prince, that the land at 648
Fourth Street be advertised for bids.
X. FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS OR REQUESTED REPORTS
Councilmember Williamson:
1. Requested scheduling a departmental debriefing meeting within thirty days to
discuss employee achievements during Hurricane Ike.
2. Requested consideration in preparing a resolution concerning the Housing
Assistance Program requesting that governmental agencies continue housing
assistance programs.
3. Requested that public announcements are made urging citizens to expedite
cleaning hurricane debris from their property.
Councilmember Henderson:
Requested that the Federal Emergency Management Association purchase the City of
Port Arthur a large generator.
Councilmember Beard:
1. Requested that an Emergency Management meeting be held in conjunction with
the debriefing meeting requested by Councilmember Williamson.
2. Requested a report on effective tax rates.
3. Report on employment utilization needs.
4. Requested revisiting City Council action regarding the repairs to Park Plaza Drive.
5. Requested a resolution designating the rotation of the prayer and the pledge for
the opening of City Council meetings.
Mavor Pro Tem Chatman
1. Requested a report on the current balance of the Council's Contingency Fund.
2. Report on the legality of utilizing mobile homes and trailers in Sabine Pass during
the rebuilding process.
The City Attorney announced that there will be a Special Meeting on October 14, 2008
at 5:30 p.m. to discuss "In-Lieu of Tax Abatements".
XI. ADJOURNMENT OF MEETING
Upon the motion by Mayor Pro Tem Chatman, seconded by Councilmember Segler and
carried unanimously, the City Council adjourned their meeting at 9:16 p.m.
An audio-tape of this meeting is on file in the office of the City Secretary and.is made a
part of the official minutes of this meeting.
MAYOR DELORIS °BOBBIE° PRINCE
City Council Minutes
Regular Meeting -September 23, 2008 g
ATTEST:
ACTING CITY SECRETARY TERRI HANKS
END OF REGULAR MEETING HELD September 23, 2008.
APPROVED:
City Council Minutes
Regular Meeting -September 23, 2008
~ ~ f
F~chibit "A"
P. O. No. 5942
09/23/08 is updated
ORDINANCE NO.
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING SECTIONS-'18-33, 58-
122, 110-94, AND 110-97 AS IT PERTAINS TO
PERMIT SCHSDIILE, TIIRN-ON CHARGE, LOCATION OF
RECREATIONAL VEHICLES AND ADJIISTMENT OF
WATER BILLS PiS A RESDLT OF HIIRRICANS IRE,
AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE
WHEREAS, the City's homes and businesses incurred. severe
damage during Hurricane Ike; and
WHEREAS, there is a need to amend Sections 18-33, 58-122,
110-94, and 110-97 as it pertains to permit schedule, turn-on
charge, location of recreational vehicles, and adjustment of
water bills as a result of Hurricane Ike, and providing an
effective date.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COIINCIL OF THE
CITY OF PORT ARTHIIR:
Section 1. That the facts and opinions in the preamble
are true and correct.
Section 2. That Subsection (b)(1) of Section 18-33 is
hereby amended to state the following:
"(1) Until September 23, 2009, there will be no building
permit fees to be charged as it pertains to homes
damages by Hurricane Ike."
Section 3. That Section 58-122. of the Code of
Ordinances is hereby amended as follows:
"Sec. 58-122. Location of Recreational Vehicles
No recreational vehicle used as a dwelling shall be parked
or laced on any tract of land or adjacent private land
within the city limits, which is not properly zoned for
such use; except, however, that this section:
z.po5942_updated_clean version
(1) Shall-not apply to residences that were damaged by
Hurricane Ike;
(a) Fora period not to exceed 90 days, the parking,
use and occupancy of .recreational vehicles on
residential property as temporary living quarters
while repairs- to these properties caused by
Hurricane Ike are ongoing.
(b) That it is hereby permitted that the building
official of the city issue a permit to allow the
occupancy of a recreational vehicle for a period
of ,six months, beyond the 90-day period, on a
residential property as temporary living quarters
by property owners while damage to these
properties caused by Hurricane Ike is being
repaired, provided that;
1) Application to the building official for a
six month extension permit shall be made no
later than 90 days from the effective date
of this section.
2) Application must be-made with all necessary
documentation to establish one of the
following: ~
(i) Substantial work is currently being
done under an active building permit
• issued by the City
(ii) Active litigation is underway with
the property owner's insurance
carrier
(iii) Application for disaster recovery
funds has been made to the City of
Port Arthur, Southeast Texas Regional
Planning Commission, or the Texas
Department of Housing and Community
Affairs and is approved or pending
.approval
(2) Shall not apply to an occupied residence or
residences that have been damaged by fire, flood, or
other natural disaster;
(a) Upon approval of the City Council
(b) For a period not to exceed 180 days, the
parking, use and occupancy of recreational
vehicles on residential property as temporary
living quarters while repairs to these
properties are ongoing:"
Section 4. That Section 110-94 is herein amended as
follows:'
z.po5942_updated clean. version
"Sec. 110-94. Turn-On Charge.
No water service will be turned on again until all charges
are paid in full or other acceptable payment arrangement made,
and shall include, but .not be limited to, all charges noticed
in Sections 110-63, 110-70(a), (b), and (c) and 110-95. When
payment is made after 3:00 p.m. and service is restored the.
same day, the turn-on charge shall be set at $35. When payment
is made before 3:00 p.m. and service is restored the same day,
the turn-on charge shall be set at $25.°
In order to assist those citizens that have been relocated
to Port Arthur as a result of Hurricane Ike, the City
waives the initial turn-on fee on the condition that the
person applying for the service can show proper
identification showing residence in one of-the affected.
areas.
In an effort to assist the non-profit organizations
providing volunteer workers in the repairing/rebuilding
homes affected by damages from Hurricane Ike, the City
waives the turn-on charge on the condition that the non-
profit organization provide property identification of
status. The.turn-on charge waiver is for a period not to
exceed one year from September 23,.2008."
Section 5. That Section 110-97 is herein amended as
follows:
"Section 110-97. Adjustment of water bills as a result of
Hurricane Ike.
The City Manager or his designee can adjust water bills up
to $1,000 for. leaks caused by Hurricane Ike beginning
September 23, 2008 to December .l, 2008. Any adjustment in
excess of $1,000 shall be forwarded to the City Council
for approval."
Section 6. That a copy of the caption of this
Ordinance be spread upon the Minutes of the City Council.
Section 7. That this being an Ordinance amending an
Ordinance which does not carry a penalty, and does not require
publication, it shall take effect immediately from and after
its passage.
READ, ADOPTED AND APPROVED on this day of
z.po9942_updated_clean version
A.D., 2008, at a Council Meeting of the City
Council of the City of Port Arthur, Texas, by the following
vote: AYES:
City Council
NOES:
MAYOR
ATTfiST:
ACTING CITY SECRETARY
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
/ 'T^N ~ G~ V '^~
CITY ATTORNEY
APPROVED FOR ADMINISTRATION:
CITY MANAGER
z.po5942_updated_ciean version
Exhibit "B"
ERHIBIT "A"
TO P. O. NO. 5943
A} In cases of extensive damage, homeowners will have to
secure a licensed-electrician to facilitate the repairs.
B) All commercial properties will need. licensed electricians
to repair their electrical systems. Once the City receives
information from electricians .that are experienced,
reliable and licensed to do business in the City of Port
Arthur that the electrical service has been repaired, the
City staff has the discretion to contact Entergy as to
connect the electrical service without inspection by city
staff
C) Subsection 18-163 (c) is herein amended to add another
subsection "6" as follows:
"(6) Until September 23, 2009, the inspection
fees for the repairs to commercial properties
damaged by Hurricane Ike will be waived up to
$1000 per structure."
z.po 5943_ezhibit a