HomeMy WebLinkAbout(3) STREET & ALLEY REPAIRSCITY OF PORT ARTHUR
UTILITY OPERATIONS DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM
To: Steve Fitzgibbons, City Manager
From: Kelly Eldridge. Director of Utility Operations
Date: March 11, 2005
File: KEMR1105
Subject: Street & Alley Repairs. Wastewater Rehabilitation Projects
This report is to bdng you and the City Council up to date with the progress our contractor
is making on the proposed street repairs as a result of sewer construction As you may
recall, Bob Shaw's first report to City Council on October 26. 2004 detailed several street
repair options that would provide a better finished product than a simple patch down or
across an old chip seal street. Those options had estimated costs associated with each, and
the Council's consensus leaned toward a double surface treatment over the entire street
width for longitudinal repairs. Mr. Shaw also discussed delays ALLCO was having getting
firm quotes from its asphalt subcontractor, CMM Construction, due to the death of two of
their managing partners/owners.
Bob Shaw provided the City Council's feedback to the contractor in order to get an actual
change order price. ALLCO's subcontractor came back with a price for the double surface
treatment that rivals the costs for an entire hot mix asphalt street ($655,500 over the contract
amount). Bob Shaw and ALLCO both acknowledge that this price is much higher than what
one would expect for this type work. Bob Shaw asked ALLCO to check with other potential
vendors to get quotes for this same work. Since that time, ALLCO has tentatively partnered
with APAC, a local paving contractor. Bob Shaw also obtained the City's latest (1995) Street
Inventory, which details each street's construction, to use in determining the method of
repair, and forwarded a copy to ALLCO. The City, Bob Shaw, ALLCO, and APAC have
subsequently been in routine contact to better define which streets/street segments will
receive which kind of repair, in order to keep everyone on the same page. For example, we
want to maintain hot mix patches on hot mix streets.
The Change Order has been prepared (copy attached), but early next week ALLCO and
APAC are scheduled to review each street individually on-site, make any revisions to the
Street Inventory and perhaps the Change Order, and get with Bob Shaw and the City to
verify what we want to accomplish. Once we all agree, we will proceed with the execution
and processing of the Change Order.
I will address restoration of improved alleys and unimproved alleys/easements separately.
Most sewer work in improved alleys is being performed in the SIMCO project (downtown
area). SIMCO has usually restored public use, improved alleys (used for sanitation
collection) as soon as practicable after construction. Unimproved alleys and easements are
a lower priority, as rainfall will consolidate the trench backfill and provide for the re-growth
of vegetation. Through experience, we have found that leveling off after backfill results in the
formation of depressions or Iow spots that hold water and become a source of nuisance and
complaints. If you let the trench receive a few rainfalls, it will settle naturally and you can
produce a better finished grade. There are no separate pay items for cleanup, except where
improvements are restored (pavement, limestone, etc.). Cleanup is a part of the contract
paid for only by the release of retainage for work complete and accepted. During the course
of these projects, we will undoubtedly perform many final inspections due to the projects'
size and length. As each area/sub-area is complete, we will inspect it for acceptance. At this
time, cleanup is the major item we look at, since most of the actual work is buried. The
contractor is anxious for acceptance so his guarantee period can begin. This, along with the
retainage on that portion of the work, is enough incentive for the contractors to complete this
task.
For the last couple of months, cleanup, even in improved alleys, has been next to impossible
due to the frequency of rainfall and Iow temperatures. Our crews still have a long list of sites
to clean up. Once the weather begins to warm up, the ground will dry much faster than when
cold, and this type work can be much more easily accomplished. As bad as these easements
and alleys may look to some, most people in this profession are amazed on how good both
of these contractor are doing with cleanup.
I have asked that Bob Shaw attend the next City Council meeting to address any questions.
I will be available to discuss this matter with you at your convenience.
xc: John Comeaux. Director of Public Works
Bob Shaw. Bob Shaw Consulting Engineers
FRGM : BOB SHAW CONSULTING ENGINEERS FAX NO. : 409 963-5101
CHANGE ORDER NO. 3
Mar. 09 ~0~5 ll:llAM P5
PAGE 1 OF 2
DATE: February 25, 2005
AGREEMENT DATE: March 10, 2004
NAME OF PROJECT: Wastewater Collection System Rehabilitation Gritting Park and Pioneer Park Areas
OWNER: City of Port Arthur, Texas
CONTRACTOR: Alice, Ltd.
The following changes are hereby made to the CONTRACT DOCUMENTS:
Add 113,212 S.Y. of full street width double asphalt surface
treatment, TxDOT Item 316~ including scarifying and
grading asphaltic pavement, @ $5.80/S.Y ..................................$656,629.60
Delete 21,759 S.Y. to remove asphaltic pavement and replace
with HMAC @ $17.00/S.Y ........................................................... $369,903.00
CHAN.GE TO CONTRACT PRICE:
ORIGINAL CONTRACT PRICE: $9,203,324.71
CURRENT CONTRACT PRICE adjusted by previous CHANGE ORDER: $9,479,532.96
The CONTRACT PRICE due to this CHANGE ORDER will be increased by: $286,726.60
The new CONTRACT PRICE including this CHANGE ORDER will be $9,766,259.56
CHANGE TO CONTRACT TIME:
ORIGINAL CONTRACT TIME: 800 Consecutive Calendar Days
CURRENT CONTRACT TIME adjusted by previous CHANGE ORDER: 958
CURRENT DATE OF COMPLETION: December 16, 2006
CONTRACT TIME due to this CHANGE ORDER will be.increased by: 0 Calendar Days
New cONTRACT TIME including this CHANGE ORDER will be 958 calendar days
The DATE FOR COMPLETION of all work will be December 16, 2008.
FROM : BOB SHAW CONSULTING ENGINEERS FAX NO. : 409 965-5101 Maw. 09 2005 11:1lAM P6
DATE: February 25, 2005
CHANGE ORDER NO.: 3
NAME OF PROJECT; Wastewater Collection System Rehabilitation
Griffing Park and Pioneer Park Areas
PAGE 2 OF 2
No other Terms and Conditions of the Contract.are changed as a result of this Change Order.
Contractor's acceptance of Change Order relieves City of any liability for additional costs incurred
by Contractor in his performance of the work covered by the Change Order.
RECOMMENDED BY:
Bob Shaw Consulting Engineers
REQUESTED BY:
AIIco, Ltd,'
CONTRACTOR, OFFICER, OR OWNER
ATTEST FOR CONTRACTOR
CORPORATE SEAL
ORDERED BY:
ACCEPTED BY:
CITY OF PORT ARTHUR
CITY OF PORT ARTHUR, MAYOR
CITY OF PORT ARTHUR, MANAGER
CITY SECRETARY
CITY SEAL
CITY ATTORNEY
APPROVED AS TO FORM